CLASS RACER FORUM

CLASS RACER FORUM (https://classracer.com/classforum/index.php)
-   Stock and Super Stock Tech (https://classracer.com/classforum/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Mixing bearings for clearance (https://classracer.com/classforum/showthread.php?t=24523)

Chris "drooze" Wertman 03-18-2010 11:29 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeff Lee (Post 176048)
Getting another rod of better quality should not take long with NHRA. I've done it in less than two weeks. Eagle and Scat are not high on my list for quality parts. Try getting a Manley, Crower or Oliver. You don't have to run a specific bolt either. There are much better bolts out there than ARP 2000's which is what I assume you have. Go for a bolt with a much higher tinsel strength which requires greater torque to stretch the same amount.
I feel this is so important that missing some races is worth it. Blow up another engine and you'll want to have a bon-fire! Just get on the phone Monday morning and get it done.

Its being done of the 3 we are building, 2 will get the Scat Rods and Diamond pistons, I wont say theyre throwaway motors, but their "life expectancy" is 5-10 events each. If we get that were good, the other the 3rd thats getting different slugs and different rods, both are "in process" to be approved and close, its an h beam rod better bolts

Im going to try to find a better bolt for these tommorow, you are right they are ARP 2000's I was going to check A1 and a couple others. These torque spec is 63 lbs ?

Pistons, well Im waiting on someone who frequents here to get on of the spec DP pistons to someone for the 5.7 the 6.1 is already in process ..... ahem :) (they were going to this week) So better options, I am half tempted to run a stock rod , that is legal as well, cant be any worse.....

I will say the first motor failed from a welded bearing and took a fastner loss, the rod took a good hit at 7k and well, it didnt break, it took a 30degree bend but held, THAT from a Scat rod I was actually suprised at, this one Ill have to look closer , if its a fastner issue, thats a lot easier to resolve FAST (Im not scat fan but that comes from years of VW friends and really nothing more than a bad association in my mind) I will say the Scat rod machine work and consistency is very spot on, suprisingly so. Others have found the same thing........so maybe just some good bolts, or better bolts I should say.

Thanks, a good point from both.....

Chris "drooze" Wertman 03-18-2010 11:36 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
That was Grubbs suggestion 5 minutes after we all saw it turn into a 13 quart oil sprinkler.

Burnout limiter is now in place. :)

Also we have no braking from the trans because of the valve body, and well so it was no load free

Bolts.....

I am curious how this failed across the other rod as well, 2 on seperate journals same bank (drivers) makes me think it was the freespin.

Hard to know until I tear it apart, for that I need, the car, for that I need my DAMM trailer fixed......wrong axle in ....BAH. Im CLOSE to saying screw it and buy a new trailer......very very close....
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich Biebel (Post 176021)
Scat parts are somewhat questionable.....probably made in China...
Rods maybe can take it...bolts sound like they failed.
Possibly you can find a better rod that you can send to NHRA for aprroval...and make sure to use good bolts no matter what rods you use.

You can't make an engine go to an rpm that it is not going to survive at and if your driver insists on trying to go to a higher rpm than is safe......there must be a rev limiter capability in your ignition......I would suggest that you use it and especially on a burnout.....It is very easy to let the rpm get away from you. I use one in my dragster......I did not use one in any of my doorcars but I have made a lot of runs and always control that rpm during a burnout......There is really no need to do a burnout more than about 500 rpm above your converters flash rpm......so 6000 or maybe a bit more is gonna be plenty........8000 is reserved for Competition Eliminator entrants......LOL


Rich Biebel 03-19-2010 07:09 AM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
Whatever rod bolt you use you have to really be carefull how you tighten the bolts and what lube you use. I once had a rod bolt failure on a Crower billet stroker rod and it was definately from improper tightening of the rod bolts. I pulled a piston out of an engine I built in a friends car. Working conditions were very poor and when I put it back together I did not have the lube I needed to get those rod bolts torqued properly. I used oil. Crower at the time sepcified oil but there was NO WAY you could get those bolts to their specified torque with plain oil. They would tend to seize up with plain oil that is likely what happened. Sometime later during the season a rod came apart and it was the one I had out. Luckily all we needed was a couple new pistons and rods.....The orginal problem was from a head that leaked water in an intake port.....

I experimented and made my own rod bolt lube...oil and moly paste mixed together......stopped the seizing as the bolts were tightened

Crower supplied an anti-seize paste with later rods......as does ARP

So My point is rod bolt lube plays a huge part in getting the bolts installed properly. I used a torque wrench for many years with no issues. I also have a rod bolt stretch gauge and have used it as well. Some rods like Olivers use an initial torque + a torque angle gauge to set the bolts......Olivers are the best in my opinion......

Another one is to make sure the bolts fit properly.......It is possible for the rod bolt head to not seat in the rod properly.....rare but possible.....

I used Manley Sportsman rods in my LT-1 Stocker a few years ago...a very good rod for a SB Chev....and would probably be good in your application if you could get something to fit.....

Chris "drooze" Wertman 03-19-2010 08:48 AM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
EXCELLENT Info.

Thanks, I have heard of a new lube from ARP that is "torque agnostic" and well that "its the ****" I have to call them and see if its "all that" but yeah oil sucks, depends all on thread finish.

Good info thanks.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich Biebel (Post 176086)
Whatever rod bolt you use you have to really be carefull how you tighten the bolts and what lube you use. I once had a rod bolt failure on a Crower billet stroker rod and it was definately from improper tightening of the rod bolts. I pulled a piston out of an engine I built in a friends car. Working conditions were very poor and when I put it back together I did not have the lube I needed to get those rod bolts torqued properly. I used oil. Crower at the time sepcified oil but there was NO WAY you could get those bolts to their specified torque with plain oil. They would tend to seize up with plain oil that is likely what happened. Sometime later during the season a rod came apart and it was the one I had out. Luckily all we needed was a couple new pistons and rods.....The orginal problem was from a head that leaked water in an intake port.....

I experimented and made my own rod bolt lube...oil and moly paste mixed together......stopped the seizing as the bolts were tightened

Crower supplied an anti-seize paste with later rods......as does ARP

So My point is rod bolt lube plays a huge part in getting the bolts installed properly. I used a torque wrench for many years with no issues. I also have a rod bolt stretch gauge and have used it as well. Some rods like Olivers use an initial torque + a torque angle gauge to set the bolts......Olivers are the best in my opinion......

Another one is to make sure the bolts fit properly.......It is possible for the rod bolt head to not seat in the rod properly.....rare but possible.....

I used Manley Sportsman rods in my LT-1 Stocker a few years ago...a very good rod for a SB Chev....and would probably be good in your application if you could get something to fit.....


Stewart Way 03-19-2010 12:38 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
Chris
Look at the Manley #14460. It is approved and $$$$ since it is the only aftermarket rod approved so far.

Alan Roehrich 03-19-2010 12:44 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
I've put in at least a couple hundred sets of Eagle rods. The only rods I've seen broke were rods that were in cylinders that had the entire cylinder wall collapse. The rods were bent nearly double before anything broke. And those were the I-beam rods. I've never had a broken Eagle H-beam rod, in anything I've built personally (and I've built plenty with them), although I know some who have.

I know several guys better than me, with more horsepower than me, and turning more RPM than me, who use Eagle H-beam rods. We have Eagle H-beam rods in the iron 427, and a new set to go in the new iron 427. They are the Eagle 6.135" H-beam rod with L-19 bolts and the "ESP Armor" option. With a 750 gram piston assembly (counting the piston, rings, locks, spacers, and pins) and turning no less than 7800 on every pass, we've got no problems.

If Eagle has an H-beam rod that will fit, get the L-19 bolts and the ESP Armor option, and get them approved, they should do fine. I know guys with 9000 RPM 850HP Super Stock engines with Eagle H-beam rods with L-19 bolts in them. If they wanted, or felt they needed, an Oliver or a Crower, I know for sure they can afford them.

Rich Biebel 03-19-2010 01:23 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
I can agree with Alan about Eagle H-beams......used them a few times and never had a failure. I had them in one of my own engines in my old dragster. Big Block alcohol injected 7 second car.......

I have seen the I beam SR rods fail though in a small block bracket engine with very few runs....

Chris "drooze" Wertman 03-19-2010 01:35 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Roehrich (Post 176142)
I've put in at least a couple hundred sets of Eagle rods. The only rods I've seen broke were rods that were in cylinders that had the entire cylinder wall collapse. The rods were bent nearly double before anything broke. And those were the I-beam rods. I've never had a broken Eagle H-beam rod, in anything I've built personally (and I've built plenty with them), although I know some who have.

I know several guys better than me, with more horsepower than me, and turning more RPM than me, who use Eagle H-beam rods. We have Eagle H-beam rods in the iron 427, and a new set to go in the new iron 427. They are the Eagle 6.135" H-beam rod with L-19 bolts and the "ESP Armor" option. With a 750 gram piston assembly (counting the piston, rings, locks, spacers, and pins) and turning no less than 7800 on every pass, we've got no problems.

If Eagle has an H-beam rod that will fit, get the L-19 bolts and the ESP Armor option, and get them approved, they should do fine. I know guys with 9000 RPM 850HP Super Stock engines with Eagle H-beam rods with L-19 bolts in them. If they wanted, or felt they needed, an Oliver or a Crower, I know for sure they can afford them.

Ill look, I know K1 has or will have an approved rod, H beam.

I need a 6.200 length and 927 pin ....

Stewart (there is a 'problem' with the Manley rods, nothing structural just an issue regarding its legality in Stock from what I understand from well people who should know .... lol)

Ill give you a call and thanks for the OP #'s

LSP 03-19-2010 07:37 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
I am going to say what others may be thinking, and don't take this the wrong way, but you need to align yourself with an stocker engine guy that knows what they are doing. Some of questions you ask, and some of the things you say about parts, rpm, and trick of the week coatings really scares me. If you don't, I'm afraid you may be in for a long, expensive education. If you do go it alone, then at least build just one motor to learn with, then if, or when, you have figured it out, spend money on the other motors you have planned. Again, don't take it as a slam, I'd just hate to see you have another oil pan failure.

Good Luck

Rich Biebel 03-19-2010 08:32 PM

Re: Mixing bearings for clearance
 
Another piece of advice........ditch the oil accumulator......I really see no reason for one on a stocker unless your playing with very low oil in the pan or it is doing giant wheelstands.......Makes no sense to have one on a car like this to me for the little gain you might get. If you had one on there and were having oil pressure loss issues....something was definately plumbed wrong....

I have one on my dragster (3 qt Moroso) and it has at times shown some erratic operation on the pressure gauge.....I believe it was from mounting clamps that were to tight and in locations on the can that could restrict the pistons movement......I took it off and moved the clamps to the outer ends of the can but have not put it back on to see if it's fixed......

I have no knowledge or experience with the oil system on one of these Mopar engines and as I recall Mopars were a little less trouble free than your run of the mill Chevs.....


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:38 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright Class Racer.com. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.