CLASS RACER FORUM

CLASS RACER FORUM (https://classracer.com/classforum/index.php)
-   Stock and Super Stock Tech (https://classracer.com/classforum/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Starter solenoid (https://classracer.com/classforum/showthread.php?t=72183)

terry1 02-09-2019 12:57 PM

Starter solenoid
 
Does anyone know, or has anyone measured, how much
current a starter solenoid draws.
Terry K

Kirk Morgan 02-09-2019 07:41 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
I have never checked how much amperage a solenoid draws. That being said, it should be only a few amps depending on if it a Ford or GM solenoid. A old school GM would be the most.What it is energizing is what is going to cause the most amps drawn. Modern permanent magnet starters will draw about 150 amps while cranking. That would be on a small block engine with 10 to one compression. The initial amperage draw would be about 20 to 25 amps more.

FED 387 02-09-2019 08:18 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
initial amperage is about 30 A ---8-10 A to keep the starter drive engaged

terry1 02-10-2019 09:58 AM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
I always thought that the solenoid was basically a relay.
This relay closes a set of contacts that allows the/a battery
wire to engage the starter.
If this is true, the actual solenoid should only require enough
current to keep it engaged.
I suspected an amp or less.
Terry K

kansas stocker 02-10-2019 10:01 AM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
FED is correct given a few amps either way. It acts like a relay but it is not.
Pete

Dragsinger 02-10-2019 10:42 AM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
To be more specific, a Ford starter solenoid and a GM solenoid or a typical aftermarket mini starter solenoid are all different in design and different in amp draw.

*The Ford solenoid/relay is, as stated above, only "making" a set of high amp carrying contacts. With this design, the amperage load is small, only a few amps.

*The GM factory style solenoid serves two purposes. First, it engages the starter drive mechanically through a lever link that is moved to engage by magnet action from the solenoid. Second, it "makes" the contacts that power the starter motor. As stated above, this design draws much more.

*The popular mini-starter design is like the GM dual function but does draw somewhat less load because of design differences.

*Just for info, another solenoid design it the 100% duty cycle style. This is what we use when installing the solenoid activated master switch.

Eman 02-10-2019 11:52 AM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by terry1 (Post 582006)
Does anyone know, or has anyone measured, how much
current a starter solenoid draws.
Terry K

What brand car, which starter solenoid. Quick giveaway is the size of the wire the factory used to activate the solenoid.
Another thing that comes into play especially on a GM starter mounted solenoid is the heat.

Dragsinger 02-10-2019 12:06 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
Eman has a good thought in ref to factory wire size. A SWAG could be ascertained in that Ford has an 18 gauge wire to bring in the solenoid whereas GM employes a 12 gauge wire.

FireSale 02-10-2019 08:09 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
i have one of those red MSD starters that probably came off a 747 based on the torque it provides. It doesn't require a Ford style relay/solenoid and has a wiring diagram that allows a 12 gauge wire to basically be connected directly to a start switch. Only problem was that this provided for the big wire on the starter to be connected directly to the battery at all times when the car was on. My steering shorted it out making a hard turn to get to the staging lanes. Burned out a 150 amp cutoff switch. I wound up wiring in a Ford solenoid to manage the battery power during start. My current headers won't clear the starter and I don't miss the drama.


On a side note, I have found that continuous duty Ford style solenoids make very good relays. They cost more but are very reliable.


Another trick: If you use a Ford style solenoid fender mounted to send power to the starter, there is a reverse voltage surge that travels on the small wire back to the starter button when the switch is released. This is caused by the collapse of the magnetic field in the solenoid and can damage the starter switch or wire to it. I replaced a push button with thin gauge wire with a beefy momentary toggle switch and 14 G wire because of this. You can also wire a diode in that small wire to block reverse current if you understand those things.

gmonde 02-10-2019 08:28 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by terry1 (Post 582006)
Does anyone know, or has anyone measured, how much
current a starter solenoid draws.
Terry K

I depends on the solenoid ,are you talking a solenoid that is part of the starter ? gm,dodge or old fords ,, some can take 8amps to operate but can hold a 100 amp to the starter,,

if you have a good multimeter it has to capability to measure the amp draw thru a amp clamp

to add if your starter motor is seasoned it will draw more amps to operate

Eman 02-10-2019 09:02 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by FireSale (Post 582084)




Another trick: If you use a Ford style solenoid fender mounted to send power to the starter, there is a reverse voltage surge that travels on the small wire back to the starter button when the switch is released. This is caused by the collapse of the magnetic field in the solenoid and can damage the starter switch or wire to it. I replaced a push button with thin gauge wire with a beefy momentary toggle switch and 14 G wire because of this. You can also wire a diode in that small wire to block reverse current if you understand those things.

This is a good point, I've had it happen but not with every GM starter when you use a Ford solenoid.
Another thing you can do is use a Ford style solenoid and use it as a relay to trigger the 12ga wire to the GM solenoid on the starter. You should use a relay on a GM starter switch circuit if you use a micro switch for a neutral safety switch.

Painter 02-11-2019 02:49 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
You guys are making this way to hard. Simply put a jumper wire between the battery post on the starter and the start terminal. Now when the “slave solinoid” is triggered it sends voltage to both terminals! Wow! How simple can you get. No small wire even going to the starter to get burned by the headers. Battery cable going to the starter is only hot when you try to start. Takes very little amperage to trip slave, and the solinoid on the starter is trip by battery voltage and amerage. Win-win situation.

Rich Biebel 02-11-2019 04:07 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
And use a Cole-Hersee HD all metal continuous duty rated slave solinoid. The plastic ones can and will stick and your starter stays engaged. None of these solinoid are as well made as they once were. I cut open a few and an old Ford style laying in my toolbox for probably 30-40 years was all copper inside. New ones use cheaper materials. It’s a very good way to keep long run battery cables from being energized all the time. Much safer ....

Eman 02-11-2019 09:04 PM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Painter (Post 582129)
You guys are making this way to hard. Simply put a jumper wire between the battery post on the starter and the start terminal. Now when the “slave solinoid” is triggered it sends voltage to both terminals! Wow! How simple can you get. No small wire even going to the starter to get burned by the headers. Battery cable going to the starter is only hot when you try to start. Takes very little amperage to trip slave, and the solinoid on the starter is trip by battery voltage and amerage. Win-win situation.

That's exactly what Firesale posted, but he also warned at how doing this can cause the starter to stay engaged at times.

FireSale 02-12-2019 02:14 AM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Painter (Post 582129)
You guys are making this way to hard. Simply put a jumper wire between the battery post on the starter and the start terminal. Now when the “slave solinoid” is triggered it sends voltage to both terminals! Wow! How simple can you get. No small wire even going to the starter to get burned by the headers. Battery cable going to the starter is only hot when you try to start. Takes very little amperage to trip slave, and the solinoid on the starter is trip by battery voltage and amerage. Win-win situation.


I have friends at the track who rebuild starters and alternators for a living and they say this shortcut will shorten the life of the starter. When you hit the switch with a jumper in the mix you send the 12 volt signal from the battery that is intended to spin the starter (up to 1000 amps) to the starter solenoid as well. That only requires 12 volts 5 to10 amps to engage the gearing and energize the motor. It will burn out the windings in the solenoid. It's just an electromagnet and a pushrod. A starter mounted solenoid has studs of different sizes for a reason. Wire it like the manufacturer intended and it will last longer.

FireSale 02-12-2019 02:30 AM

Re: Starter solenoid
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Eman (Post 582166)
That's exactly what Firesale posted, but he also warned at how doing this can cause the starter to stay engaged at times.


Kind of. The starter positive post was always hot and shorted against my steering. Here is the simple wiring diagram from an MSD Dynaforce starter. The one I ran the starter positive through a Ford solenoid. A little too simple.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright Class Racer.com. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.