Broken SBC crankshaft

[Mike Pearson]

Well my season ended early at the Jackson pro am last weekend. The crankshaft broke right behind the #8 rod journal. Several runs before the broken crank I had an oil pump snap off at the neck and fell into the pan. The engine was completely freshened and had the crank turned .010. Might have been some residual damage from the oil pump hitting the crank. Also the #4 main bearing was burned pretty bad. Other than the #4 main all of the other bearings looked good. What are some of you using for crankshafts. I think the one in the engine might have been an Eagle lightweight. Super Stock 350/295/313 SBC 2.00" rod journals. Thanks.

[GregP]

Callies has a really good stock and superstock crankshaft from what I have seen.

[joespanova]

Originally Posted by Mike Pearson

Well my season ended early at the Jackson pro am last weekend. The crankshaft broke right behind the #8 rod journal. Several runs before the broken crank I had an oil pump snap off at the neck and fell into the pan. The engine was completely freshened and had the crank turned .010. Might have been some residual damage from the oil pump hitting the crank. Also the #4 main bearing was burned pretty bad. Other than the #4 main all of the other bearings looked good. What are some of you using for crankshafts. I think the one in the engine might have been an Eagle lightweight. Super Stock 350/295/313 SBC 2.00" rod journals. Thanks.

BRC 4340 .........which has chromed rod journals. This crank has been through hell.........passes mag check , straightness every time.
First time , ( in '01 ) a Manley aluminum rod broke. Crank kicked it right through the block.
Last year.......
I lost an engine from what I thought was a rod failure ( aluminum ) and turned out to be an oil pump bypass spring breaking ( no oil pressure ) .
Sent the rod through the block , again.
Last time.........recent , apparently the damage from the previous carnage above fractured / cracked the oil pump drive shaft and I didnt see it.............it broke , and I lost oil pressure AGAIN , only this time I caught it before it killed everything. Polished crank , sent rods to GRP for evaluation.........they replaced 2 rods because they were a little out of shape on the big end. And let me just say this.........GRP is a stand up company because they replaced those 2 rods at ZERO charge to me.
Those rods had 14 runs on them at the time.
So as you can see , my crank / cranks take a beating and come back for more.........

[Mike Taylor 3601]

if crank wasn't magnafluxed when ground, may have been cracked and then broke.
#4 main bad and others good sounds like crank was cracked and rubbing bearing before it broke, if look closely may see where #3 and # 5 main bearings have been rubbed some,most of the time when you have a few main bearings rubbed/wiped out the crank will be cracked and flexing.
Was the radius left in crank when reground?If had 1/8 radius and it was cut less or square that weakens the crank also.
When I tear into engine with broken oil pump,I check balance of rotating assembly,clearance between oil pump shaft and block and oil pump pick up/pan clearance.
but there is chance since most bearings were OK that crank broke and vibration from that broke oil pump.
Mike Taylor 3601,

[Mike Pearson]

Originally Posted by Mike Taylor 3601

if crank wasn't magnafluxed when ground, may have been cracked and then broke.
#4 main bad and others good sounds like crank was cracked and rubbing bearing before it broke, if look closely may see where #3 and # 5 main bearings have been rubbed some,most of the time when you have a few main bearings rubbed/wiped out the crank will be cracked and flexing.
Was the radius left in crank when reground?If had 1/8 radius and it was cut less or square that weakens the crank also.
When I tear into engine with broken oil pump,I check balance of rotating assembly,clearance between oil pump shaft and block and oil pump pick up/pan clearance.
but there is chance since most bearings were OK that crank broke and vibration from that broke oil pump.
Mike Taylor 3601,

Unfortunately we did not magnaflux the crank before it was ground. The radius on the crank was real nice when we got it back from the grinder. The break was right in the same area that would have been damaged from the oil pump breaking off. the burned bearing has me puzzled though. Maybe the cracked crank was pushing some metal through the system but the two rod bearings next to the broken area were still good. The newer model of the Melling M55 pumps are known to break. I replaced that with a moroso billet pump on that last freshen up. I also put a low oil pressure warning light in the car. I shut the engine down as soon as that lit up.

[BillK]

Originally Posted by Mike Pearson

Unfortunately we did not magnaflux the crank before it was ground.

That's why I like the guy that grinds cranks for my shop. He simply WILL NOT grind a crank without magnafluxing it first. He has found plenty of cracked ones over the years, they go in the scrap pile

[Alan Roehrich]

It has been my experience that the vast majority of crankshafts that fail from fatigue fail either in front of #1 rod journal, or behind #8.


For an aftermarket crank, I strongly suggest Callies, I don't think you'll find anything better for Stock Eliminator or Super Stock.