CLASS RACER FORUM

CLASS RACER FORUM (https://classracer.com/classforum/index.php)
-   Stock and Super Stock (https://classracer.com/classforum/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   HP Adjustments are posted (https://classracer.com/classforum/showthread.php?t=78115)

jmcarter 12-18-2020 01:59 PM

HP Adjustments are posted
 
http://www.nhraracer.com/

I’ll reserve comment but some entertainment value to say the least

MR DERBY CITY 12-18-2020 02:32 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Damn !!!!!!!!! .....happy holidays. !!!!!!

rtaylor3410 12-18-2020 02:34 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Be sure to check the classification guides and engine blueprint specs too. There are changes that were not posted there as well. For example, 1987 Chevy Camaro 305 190 combo went from 240hp to 245hp and engine specs changed from flat hydraulic to hydraulic roller.,

ALMACK 12-18-2020 02:46 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rtaylor3410 (Post 630071)
Be sure to check the classification guides and engine blueprint specs too. There are changes that were not posted there as well. For example, 1987 Chevy Camaro 305 190 combo went from 240hp to 245hp and engine specs changed from flat hydraulic to hydraulic roller.,

^^ this is true.

Adub464Q 12-18-2020 03:55 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Am I reading this correct.....

2011-2014 Mustang Combo with 26 hp off?

KRatcliff 12-18-2020 04:07 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Adub464Q (Post 630078)
Am I reading this correct.....

2011-2014 Mustang Combo with 26 hp off?

Makes you wonder. I don't see anyone running that combo on Nitro Joes stats. I was told that no runs, no HP reduction will be considered directly by Pat. Guess that rule was just for me.

Whalen3186 12-18-2020 04:34 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
According to the rule book, once an engine family receives a hp increase, it is never eligible for a hp decrease.

Stock had 7 combinations get a reduction. 3 of those combos had an NHRA hp rating higher than the OEM rating:

1977 Malibu: OEM = 160-170, Old = 275, New = 271
1969 Roadrunner: OEM = 390, Old = 400, New = 395
1986 T'bird OEM = 150, Old = 200, New = 197

How were these eligible for a reduction?

KRatcliff 12-18-2020 04:57 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whalen3186 (Post 630080)
According to the rule book, once an engine family receives a hp increase, it is never eligible for a hp decrease.

Stock had 7 combinations get a reduction. 3 of those combos had an NHRA hp rating higher than the OEM rating:

1977 Malibu: OEM = 160-170, Old = 275, New = 271
1969 Roadrunner: OEM = 390, Old = 400, New = 395
1986 T'bird OEM = 150, Old = 200, New = 197

How were these eligible for a reduction?

I was wondering that too, but I have given up on equal enforcement of the rules or even simple enforcement of the rules as written.

Lee Valentine 12-18-2020 05:30 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
[QUOTE=rtaylor3410;630071]Be sure to check the classification guides and engine blueprint specs too. There are changes that were not posted there as well. For example, 1987 Chevy Camaro 305 190 combo went from 240hp to 245hp and engine specs changed from flat hydraulic to hydraulic roller

Frank Castros 12-18-2020 06:39 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whalen3186 (Post 630080)
According to the rule book, once an engine family receives a hp increase, it is never eligible for a hp decrease.

Stock had 7 combinations get a reduction. 3 of those combos had an NHRA hp rating higher than the OEM rating:

1977 Malibu: OEM = 160-170, Old = 275, New = 271
1969 Roadrunner: OEM = 390, Old = 400, New = 395
1986 T'bird OEM = 150, Old = 200, New = 197

How were these eligible for a reduction?

I’m not familiar with that rule, however the Six Pack needed it in C for sure. John Leach must be pleased but I’m sure he wished for more. Beep Beep!

Lee Valentine 12-18-2020 06:40 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rtaylor3410 (Post 630071)
Be sure to check the classification guides and engine blueprint specs too. There are changes that were not posted there as well. For example, 1987 Chevy Camaro 305 190 combo went from 240hp to 245hp and engine specs changed from flat hydraulic to hydraulic roller.,

this is a kick in the nuts,all of a sudden we have 2 engines that are illegal after being built to the rules. And after we make them right we get 5 more horsepower and 60 lbs.

rick winchester 12-18-2020 06:45 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Not sure about the others but looks like the change in the Malibu is for aftermarket heads only. already 270 for stock heads. Rick

MikeMoller 12-18-2020 07:06 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KRatcliff (Post 630079)
Makes you wonder. I don't see anyone running that combo on Nitro Joes stats. I was told that no runs, no HP reduction will be considered directly by Pat. Guess that rule was just for me.

I was told by Pat C that if the NHRA HP was less than the factory hp it could be considered for a reduction. Most of the reductions fit that, but not all. Curious.Also, the 76 and 77 305 novas both got hit, but only the 77 had runs to cause the hit. They didn't do that to the 302 FFFFords 75-78.

KRatcliff 12-18-2020 07:17 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Frank Castros (Post 630088)
I’m not familiar with that rule, however the Six Pack needed it in C for sure. John Leach must be pleased but I’m sure he wished for more. Beep Beep!

Apparently neither is the person from the NHRA that reduced the combo. This is directly from the AHFS rule book. "Once an engine family receives a horsepower increase it is not eligible for a decrease."

http://www.nhraracer.com/content/gen...633&zoneid=132

Paul Wong 12-18-2020 07:19 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whalen3186 (Post 630080)
According to the rule book, once an engine family receives a hp increase, it is never eligible for a hp decrease.

Stock had 7 combinations get a reduction. 3 of those combos had an NHRA hp rating higher than the OEM rating:

1977 Malibu: OEM = 160-170, Old = 275, New = 271
1969 Roadrunner: OEM = 390, Old = 400, New = 395
1986 T'bird OEM = 150, Old = 200, New = 197

How were these eligible for a reduction?

Many of those above OEM HP ratings were picked by NHRA officials at the time that assigned a "reasonable HP factor" to the combination. Some of these reasonable assignments were as bad as the inflated 1960s numbers some of the manufacturers assigned. There were some combinations were given as much as 75hp without ever being run. Some needed it others were made into filler for the guide instantly.

KRatcliff 12-18-2020 07:23 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeMoller (Post 630092)
I was told by Pat C that if the NHRA HP was less than the factory hp it could be considered for a reduction. Most of the reductions fit that, but not all. Curious.Also, the 76 and 77 305 novas both got hit, but only the 77 had runs to cause the hit. They didn't do that to the 302 FFFFords 76-78.

In the case of the reduction I was referring to had the NHRA HP and Factory HP the same before this reduction of 26 hp which was a 10% gift. Pretty big one by anybody's standard.

Pat C told me that no runs will not get any consideration for a HP reduction. This combo didn't have any runs nor was it meeting the other criteria that he quoted you. Makes me question the motive, but they don't care what we think. That is the only constant.

Whalen3186 12-18-2020 07:46 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Wong (Post 630094)
Many of those above OEM HP ratings were picked by NHRA officials at the time that assigned a "reasonable HP factor" to the combination. Some of these reasonable assignments were as bad as the inflated 1960s numbers some of the manufacturers assigned. There were some combinations were given as much as 75hp without ever being run. Some needed it others were made into filler for the guide instantly.

Paul, That makes sense and I wondered if that was the case with any of these particular combo’s. I figured somebody like you with some historical knowledge of various combos would know.

Frank B. 12-18-2020 08:24 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
I asked for look at 2010 Camaro SS at 400 hp with less lift cam and less compression than 2015 Camaro. Got no response.

Jeff Stout 12-18-2020 09:11 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
In addition, the engine family must NOT make two runs of 0.650 or quicker or any run 0.850 or quicker during the past two (2) review periods, for the review to continue. Once an engine family receives a horsepower increase it is not eligible for a decrease.
For the ones with more then factoryHP. It's based off increases over the past 2 reviews that are not eligible.

ALMACK 12-18-2020 09:29 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whalen3186 (Post 630080)
According to the rule book, once an engine family receives a hp increase, it is never eligible for a hp decrease.

Stock had 7 combinations get a reduction. 3 of those combos had an NHRA hp rating higher than the OEM rating:

1977 Malibu: OEM = 160-170, Old = 275, New = 271
1969 Roadrunner: OEM = 390, Old = 400, New = 395
1986 T'bird OEM = 150, Old = 200, New = 197

How were these eligible for a reduction?

The '86 T-Bird 302 combo ( 150 hp ) has been 197 h.p. since Jan. 01, 2015

So it's not a reduction

https://scontent-atl3-1.xx.fbcdn.net...3f&oe=60017225

KRatcliff 12-18-2020 10:06 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ALMACK (Post 630100)
The '86 T-Bird 302 combo ( 150 hp ) has been 197 h.p. since Jan. 01, 2015

So it's not a reduction

https://scontent-atl3-1.xx.fbcdn.net...3f&oe=60017225

Could it have been increased to 200 since 2015 then reduced back to 197 1/1/2021? Because the current guide shows the date of 1/1/2021 for the 197 hp rating.

Edited to add: I did a little digging and this combo did get a HP increase at the end of 2018 from 197 to 200.

http://www.nhraracer.com/content/gen...311&zoneid=132

Whalen3186 12-18-2020 10:32 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KRatcliff (Post 630103)
Could it have been increased to 200 since 2015 then reduced back to 197 1/1/2021? Because the current guide shows the date of 1/1/2021 for the 197 hp rating.

Edited to add: I did a little digging and this combo did get a HP increase at the end of 2018 from 197 to 200.

http://www.nhraracer.com/content/gen...311&zoneid=132

According to Nitro Joe’s Stats Nanette Stein was running this combo at Sonoma LODRS and ran faster than -.65 in qualifying and first round. If that is indeed true, how did it qualify for a reduction?

DRC lists the entry as an 89 so I’m not sure which is true.
https://www.dragracecentral.com/DRCS...r2020#indextop

KRatcliff 12-18-2020 10:49 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whalen3186 (Post 630104)
According to Nitro Joe’s Stats Nanette Stein was running this combo at Sonoma LODRS and ran faster than -.65 in qualifying and first round. If that is indeed true, how did it qualify for a reduction?

DRC lists the entry as an 89 so I’m not sure which is true.
https://www.dragracecentral.com/DRCS...r2020#indextop

The 1989 would not be correct because it isn't in the guide as a 302 150 factory 200 NHRA rated. It would have to be a 1986 as Nitro Joe indicates. From the AHFS rule book "In addition, the engine family must NOT make two runs of 0.650 or quicker or any run 0.850 or quicker during the past two (2) review periods, for the review to continue."

The Sonoma divisional wasn't a mineshaft race so those two runs alone would have made the combo ineligible IF the NHRA followed their own rule book, but who knows why they do what they do.

JHeath 12-18-2020 11:02 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whalen3186 (Post 630104)
According to Nitro Joe’s Stats Nanette Stein was running this combo at Sonoma LODRS and ran faster than -.65 in qualifying and first round. If that is indeed true, how did it qualify for a reduction?

DRC lists the entry as an 89 so I’m not sure which is true.
https://www.dragracecentral.com/DRCS...r2020#indextop

That car isn't a 1989 T Bird

ALMACK 12-18-2020 11:18 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KRatcliff (Post 630103)
Could it have been increased to 200 since 2015 then reduced back to 197 1/1/2021? Because the current guide shows the date of 1/1/2021 for the 197 hp rating.

Edited to add: I did a little digging and this combo did get a HP increase at the end of 2018 from 197 to 200.

http://www.nhraracer.com/content/gen...311&zoneid=132

Not sure.

There used to be a line on NHRA's site about the 3 year deal. They have since deleted it.
Used to be a combo was not eligible for a reduction for 3 years after an increase.

KRatcliff 12-18-2020 11:47 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ALMACK (Post 630107)
Not sure.

There used to be a line on NHRA's site about the 3 year deal. They have since deleted it.
Used to be a combo was not eligible for a reduction for 3 years after an increase.

You can see from my link it was increased 2 years ago, but the time frame doesn't matter because this is the AHFS rule regarding past increases. "Once an engine family receives a horsepower increase it is not eligible for a decrease."

That is only one of the reasons why it shouldn't be eligible. The other one is what Drew pointed out. That combo had too many runs -.650 or quicker. There are multiple reasons why it wouldn't be eligible based on the rules as written, but it appears those are only suggestions. Or more commonly referred to by the NHRA as "clerical errors."

MR DERBY CITY 12-19-2020 12:15 AM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KRatcliff (Post 630108)
Or more commonly referred to by the NHRA as "clerical errors."

For those keeping score, CLERICAL ERRORS .....is code name for Pat Cevengros ....

Larry Hill 12-19-2020 08:21 AM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
If the largest HP reduction annually is 2.25% based on a current year run of no quicker than -0.101 to -0.165 how does the 1962 Pontiac 421/ 405 go from 385 HP to 360 HP. 2.25 % of 385 is, after rounding, is 9 HP not 25 HP. It looks like the 227/ 260 Ford received more than 2.25% reduction. After rounding the power should be 254 not the 234.

I would bet that after the first of the year the numbers will be more accurate.

Larry Hill 12-19-2020 08:36 AM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
NHRA posted 11/16/21 as the cutoff date for accepting reduction requests for the 2021 season.
Thank you!

Tom Johnston 12-19-2020 09:12 AM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Huh, I sure don't remember asking Santa for three more HP!

Dave Gantz 12-19-2020 12:24 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Is it any wonder people bracket race?

Brett C 12-19-2020 09:00 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
Relax everyone! Jeez! It’s just typos!

James L Miller 12-20-2020 11:21 PM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
I wish I had known about this combo before. I could have made twice the factory power.

Super Stock Horsepower No Changes


OEM NHRA

Make CID HP HP Years Affected
Mopar 360 48 440 1970 Challenger*

Jared Jordan 12-21-2020 10:57 AM

Re: HP Adjustments are posted
 
The ‘69 Roadrunner is for the replacement head. I don’t think anyone is running that yet, but may very well be wrong (didn’t look...).

The factory head is rated at 380. The better combo right now, anyway.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright Class Racer.com. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.