worst red light debate, again!

[bill dedman]

Originally Posted by Andys dad

Hey Bill - Ron Here (as it says at the bottom of my posts)

Why not deal with one thing at a time - this thread was about red lights

You did not answer what is UNFAIR about both losing - if both red light

Answer this and then lets start a new thread on break outs



I realize this forum is a form of entertainmenet for you and others

It is a debating society and it is entertaining at times




BTW - BOs use to be the way you described

Ron,

Sorry; somehow I missed your posted name. My bad...

No, I don't see anything unfair about disqualifying both cars that redlight.
Having said that, I would also like to say that I don't see that it accomplishes anything, other than "thinning the herd" as it makes its way toward a final round. Additionally, I think that some degree of consistency in the rules, is a good thing, and this disqualifying BOTH red lighters would be in contention with the way breakouts are treated (WORSE breakout loses.)

I don't see that dual protocol as a good thing; do you? In the interest of consistency and simplicity, I think they should both be the same; "worse infraction loses."

What we have now, is schizoid.